View Poll Results: What motor
|
LQ9, iron motor, $800ish 187lbs
|
  
|
14 |
58.33% |
LS2, aluminum motor, $2k-3kish 87lbs
|
  
|
10 |
41.67% |
01-25-2009
|
#41
|
Reynolds number user
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: grove/tempe
Posts: 3,553
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Hell no dont stay away from a chevy v8! If there is one thing gm can do its build a good v8.
The vh45 would be unique, but thats about it. It may be a great engine (as well as the 1UZ) but the amount of support in this country is lacking for those engines. Whereas with the gm engines there are thousands of people out there that know everything about them. Plus if you wanted to mod it, which of course you will, you get to pick from millions of low priced domestic parts.
__________________
07 Ducati Monster S4R
00 honda elite 50 (64 mph braH!)
05 malaguti F15
04 E55 AMG
|
|
|
01-25-2009
|
#42
|
is Nashty
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Stillwater
Drives: Cyborg from Japan
Posts: 2,080
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Quote:
Originally Posted by b00stcreep21
Do you actually have any information, or a logical reason for that statment, or have you just seen F&F one too many times?
|
I wont waste my breath explaining it to you.. But I guess these guys watch too much F&F too..
Quote:
Originally Posted by Swifty1638
besides being one of the best designed engines in the world, capable of good numbers and good spool time, I also thought the 2jz was a bit on the lighter end..for being a 6-cyl.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by GSXMatt
I say 2JZGTE + massive single.
|
__________________
-1990 Mitsubishi Cyborg 4WD-
|
|
|
01-25-2009
|
#43
|
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
I'd definitely go for the LS motor over the LQ if your concerned about weight and handling.
Math time: If an LS would get you a 51/49 and an LQ is only 100lbs heavier (and all of the extra weight goes on the front axle only), on a 2800 lb (now 2900 with an LQ) car that gets you to 51.7/48.3. Not as good, but if it gets you the power you want for a lot less coin, it's not that big of a sacrifice.
Even the almighty handling god know as the EVO is way worse than that at 60/40 or there abouts depending on the model.
You can definitely feel the difference from a balanced car to and unbalanced car. Conquests are near 50/50 stock and getting in my Grand Am after that, even taking corners at a moderate pace (clover leafs in particular) you could just feel the front left was really loaded up.
I'd defiantly say no to ANY motor that doesn't have a good after market for it. It will be big bucks (or lots of work) for small gains, and in the end a mildly built LS/LQ would probably still make more power. There is no replacement for displacement. You can make up the difference with boost, until the guy with more displacement adds boost too.
I'd go for an LS2 if I was doing it, they handle boost ok, but I'd probably just do a head/cam package and be happy with a nice reliable 400whp car.
BMW S52 if you going to do a I6. But an LS would be cheaper and make more power.
Last edited by MustGoFaster; 01-25-2009 at 11:04 PM..
|
|
|
01-25-2009
|
#44
|
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 79
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Quote:
Originally Posted by turbotalon1g
^True that.
Carl do you have any more infomation on it? Cost?
Apparently the motor is pretty wide it would be a tight squeeze.
Not doubted teh badassery of the VH, just the cost and size of me wallet.
|
we bought an entire donor car (q45) and an entire second engine for about 1k lol. but yes, it is a rather wide engine and was a bit of a chore to fit into an s13.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Super Bleeder!!
Hell no dont stay away from a chevy v8! If there is one thing gm can do its build a good v8.
The vh45 would be unique, but thats about it. It may be a great engine (as well as the 1UZ) but the amount of support in this country is lacking for those engines. Whereas with the gm engines there are thousands of people out there that know everything about them. Plus if you wanted to mod it, which of course you will, you get to pick from millions of low priced domestic parts.
|
that is probably the major set-back, due to it's uniqueness and general lack of support it may be hard to go super crazy with it. on the other hand, most piston/rod manufacturers can custom make you stuff for relatively decent costs (JE is making me custom pistons for $640 including hardware) - probably be based off other nissan parts (vq30det has the same bore I believe)
__________________

91 gvr4 dd, 04 open class sti rally car, 97 k2500 toy hauler
2010 events: sno*drift, 100AW, STPR, OFR, LSPR, NT1-3
|
|
|
01-25-2009
|
#45
|
aka Goodbye
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Isn't the Nissan engine aluminum? If that's the case, then you need to compare the Corvette LS motor, which is quite a bit more than the iron block versions. It's about the uniqueness and keeping the family bloodline.
|
|
|
01-25-2009
|
#46
|
Reynolds number user
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: grove/tempe
Posts: 3,553
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Goat Blower
Isn't the Nissan engine aluminum? If that's the case, then you need to compare the Corvette LS motor, which is quite a bit more than the iron block versions. It's about the uniqueness and keeping the family bloodline.
|
The F-bodies got the aluminum LS1 as well, so they arent really $$$.
__________________
07 Ducati Monster S4R
00 honda elite 50 (64 mph braH!)
05 malaguti F15
04 E55 AMG
|
|
|
01-25-2009
|
#48
|
Banned
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Boulder, CO
Drives: Conquest
Posts: 5,049
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
I wouldn't go chevy v8 simply for the fact that everyone else has done it.
I changed my mind, you need a v12 in that thing with 4 turbos.
|
|
|
01-26-2009
|
#49
|
Is funding Exxon.
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Ham Lake
Drives: like a bat outta hell!
Posts: 7,983
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MustGoFaster
BMW S52 if you going to do a I6. But an LS would be cheaper and make more power.
|
Do you mean S54? They are nice for NA, but definately go LS series. I also vote for the LS2 if you can swing it, they are bad ass. If you are getting a new engine the LS3 is basically the same price and even more bad ass (.040" overbore of an LS2 with better heads). My next toy car will be motivated by a boosted LSx engine, probably a LS3. The LS stuff has so much support and they make power so easily, it is hard not to go that route. Yeah, lots of people do it, but there is a reason for it!
__________________
Is burning corn and stayin' warm!
My motorcycle is stock and reliable, my Talon is neither!
|
|
|
01-26-2009
|
#50
|
Wanker
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: St Paul, MN
Drives: 95 M3
Posts: 1,027
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Quote:
Originally Posted by M/// Guy
Ill throw out another option. E39 M5 V8 
|
There is the easy 400 ponies in a light(ish) package. Have fun finding a low mileage one for any kind of reasonable money.
Lots of great engines in the world, but it's really hard to beat LSx for simplicity, affordability, reliability and aftermarket support.
|
|
|
01-26-2009
|
#51
|
Banned
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Quote:
Originally Posted by GSXMatt
I say 2JZGTE + massive single.
|
X2
Quote:
Originally Posted by Super Bleeder!!
GM 4.3L vortec I6 out of the Trailblazer.
|
FYI Its actually a 4.2L I6..
http://autos.msn.com/research/vip/Sp...el=TrailBlazer
Last edited by GREASEMONKEY; 01-26-2009 at 04:41 AM..
|
|
|
01-26-2009
|
#52
|
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JET
Do you mean S54?
|
No, I figured the S52 would be cheaper and easier to find.
To the people that say no to an LS engine "cause everybody has done it". There is a reason. Great motor, small package, bang for the buck.
Let's get a list of all motors suggested, with Price (including wiring/ECU) Hp/Tq ratings and if you can find it, weight fully dressed with accessories. Let the numbers decide. So far this is just the Chevy V8 guys VS. the "NO Chevy bad" guys putting up arguments that I haven't seen backed by facts for both sides (in the same argument). And I'm just as guilty as anyone. To me this is the smart way. Make a list comparing all the important features. Maybe we should inlude aftermarket support and power potential as well? But those can be slightly subjective. Also tunning! GM's can be flashed easy. Some of the older stuff is going to depend on other more expensive solutions.
LS1 $4500 (ebay) Engine/T56/Harnness/Computer 69K miles from an '02 WS6 325 HP/350 TQ
LS2 $7100 (ebay) Engine/T56/Harnness/Computer 39K miles From an '05 GTO 400hp/395 TQ
LQ4 $3495 (ebay) Engine/4L60E/Harness/Computer 20Kmiles '06 Silverado 300 HP/360 TQ
LQ9 $2000 (ebay) Engine/Harness/computer NO TRANS 42K miles 04 Escalade 345 HP/380 TQ
^Excelent aftermarket
4.2L Vortec I6
2JZGTE $1800-2900 (ebay) Engine/AT cheap, 5speed spendy, Comp/harness Milage unkown "280 hp" 318 ft·lb JDM version. 320 hp 315 TQ USDM
1UZFE
VH45 $1000-3000 (used car) Engine/Trans/Comp/Harness 100K+ miles 278 hp 292 Tq Poor aftermarket
RB25
RB26
4G63
4B11t
6G72
6G74
6G75
BMW S52
BMW S54
BMW S62 (E39 M5 V8)
???
Last edited by MustGoFaster; 01-26-2009 at 12:09 PM..
|
|
|
01-26-2009
|
#53
|
formerly ecoli
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: On the dyno
Posts: 4,892
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
The 2JZ is very heavy. You put in alum V8s that weigh less. If you want to do it on the cheap, then do an earlier 2JZGE, instead of the GTE. But I think one of your main concerns should be what affordable tranny with bolt up easy to whichever motor you go with. There are a few tranny options for the 2JZ, but non are close to cheap. It depends if you are looking for 300hp or 1000hp though.
|
|
|
01-26-2009
|
#54
|
is Nashty
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Stillwater
Drives: Cyborg from Japan
Posts: 2,080
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
1000hp or bust! 
__________________
-1990 Mitsubishi Cyborg 4WD-
|
|
|
01-26-2009
|
#55
|
formerly ecoli
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: On the dyno
Posts: 4,892
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Will his Z chassis even handle any power.
|
|
|
01-26-2009
|
#56
|
Is funding Exxon.
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Ham Lake
Drives: like a bat outta hell!
Posts: 7,983
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
I think 700whp is pretty rediculous if you want it to handle also. I have the LQ4 (325hp) in our Denali XL. It is pretty amazing how well it hauls around over 5,000 lbs, it scoots pretty good. I think if you got an LS2 with bolt ons and put out 500+whp, you would be happy in a light car. NA would be good for the twisty tracks too. If you decide that isn't enough you can always turbo it later.
Here is a good option:
http://texas-speed.com/shop/item.asp...d=828&catid=85
__________________
Is burning corn and stayin' warm!
My motorcycle is stock and reliable, my Talon is neither!
|
|
|
01-26-2009
|
#57
|
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Blaine, MN
Drives: '91 Automagic
Posts: 13,908
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
^That is pretty much the plan sir.
I thought that by adding boost I wouldn't lose the NA power that would be perfect for Auto-x type stuff.
I do plan to boost it later on.
I think JET, RYAN, FLOPPY have said it perfectly and right now the major choice is between the LQ9 and LS1/2.
The Z chassis will need some work to hold this power, but the aftermarket for handling is sweet.
I dont know about that jet my man, thats a ton of money. I know someone with an LS6 pull out from a C5 Zo6 might see how much he wants for that.
The iron can handle power without being built, but the aluminum not so much. It would be tapped with heads/cam and maybe 50-100shot.
The yellow Z with an LQ4 formerly owned by titanium a local on MNSC sold to a guy 4 hours away in WI, I am talking to him now and might go get a ride in it.
I started a thread over there and an admin/shop owner said its up to you and what you feel and locked it right away so yeah.
I thank everyone for the helpful input. Remember I am not baller, I usually end up sacrificing food and clothes to work/fund my car.
|
|
|
01-26-2009
|
#58
|
New Member
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Minneapolis/MN/USA
Posts: 6
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Last edited by titanium; 01-26-2009 at 08:46 PM..
|
|
|
01-26-2009
|
#59
|
Is funding Exxon.
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Ham Lake
Drives: like a bat outta hell!
Posts: 7,983
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Quote:
Originally Posted by turbotalon1g
The iron can handle power without being built, but the aluminum not so much. It would be tapped with heads/cam and maybe 50-100shot.
|
The LS1 blocks were much weaker than the LS2 blocks. LS2 blocks are taking 300hp shots of nitrous and have made over 900whp. I wouldn't do the LS6, the LS2 is much better. Look for a later model GTO or that vette place by us on 65.
__________________
Is burning corn and stayin' warm!
My motorcycle is stock and reliable, my Talon is neither!
|
|
|
01-27-2009
|
#60
|
Banned
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Boulder, CO
Drives: Conquest
Posts: 5,049
|
Re: What motor would you choose? To put in a Z car.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MustGoFaster
To the people that say no to an LS engine "cause everybody has done it". There is a reason. Great motor, small package, bang for the buck.
|
I was pretty much the only one who said it blatantly, so you can call me out on it.
It's just personal preference; opinion as some would say. I don't deny it is a good package and bang for the buck, but he did mention that he wanted something a little different.
|
|
|
Posting Rules
|
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off
|
|
|
|
|