If you want to do it like a pro see these videos by 3M.
http://www.3m.com/us/auto_marine_aer...eo/index.jhtml
The "Bumper Tab Repair" vid would be the one to watch in this case.
I'm guessing that's way more time and money then you want to put in to this. But the info could come in handy some day.
Threaded Mode