MitsuStyle

MitsuStyle (http://www.mitsustyle.com/forums/index.php)
-   Turbo / Engine / Drivetrain (http://www.mitsustyle.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=91)
-   -   T3 vs. Mitsu housing (http://www.mitsustyle.com/forums/showthread.php?t=21251)

turbotalon1g 11-04-2008 03:04 PM

T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Can anyone explain the differences/ pros vs. cons of these?
i am looking at turbo's about 50 trim sized and I have the opportunity to go T3 instead of bolt on, just wondering if i should.
To me if i have the same turbo, by going T3 I would lose spool but gain topend.

scheides 11-04-2008 03:15 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Two primary differences. One, you'll have to go to an aftermarket manifold. This will usually be a tubular-style setup, cost a lot, possibly crack over time, and more specifically yield more top-end power and sacrifice a bit of bottom-end.

The T3 hotsides you'd go with either a .63 or .86. Smaller = better spool, less top end, and vice versa. On a 50-trim on a 2.0, the smaller hotside will likely be ideal.

The bolt-on hotides are usually small-ish to somewhere in between, comparable to a .74 or so.

turbotalon1g 11-04-2008 04:21 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
To be exact, I am looking at an HX35 in either a bolt-on .55 a/r or T3 .70 a/r.
Spool in bolt-on is said to be comparable to E316G but top end has been reported 50lb/min+, a friend of mine is seeing 49 lb/min @26psi.

At-Least-It's-An-Evo 11-04-2008 04:33 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by turbotalon1g (Post 263322)
To be exact, I am looking at an HX35 in either a bolt-on .55 a/r or T3 .70 a/r.
Spool in bolt-on is said to be comparable to E316G but top end has been reported 50lb/min+, a friend of mine is seeing 49 lb/min @26psi.

Looks like a HX35 compressor wheel or whatever flows 55-60 lbs a minute is what the general info after googling says. Thats more than that evo16g will flow but I highly doubt it will spool as fast. You know there will always be a trade off for spool vs. more flow... right?

If you hated the sc61 or whatever you had, you'll probably hate the HX35 too.

turbotalon1g 11-04-2008 04:42 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Yes I understand that, I guess what I am trying to do here is gain more top end, but not so much lag that comes with it.
I can say that there are times when I miss the 61.
That is why I am going for this, its along the lines of a 50 trim, which I think I will be happy with on the scm61 I had 20psi by 4200rpm.
I guess I would like this a bit earlier maybe late 3000s (3500-3900).
The bolton housing on a HX35 has dyno'd 500whp on a few cars. (yes we all know dynos are diff, but I have a baseline of this setup and want to improve a bit)

Shane@DBPerformance 11-04-2008 05:26 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
A/R is just a ratio like trim, they don't mean a whole lot unless you are comparing to other housing in the same family. A .64 A/R T25 housing is tiny compared to a T3 .63 A/R. A T3 .82 A/R probably falls into line some where between a .58 and .68 T4 exhaust housing for spoolup/power. The PTE Mitsu .63 A/Rs are a tad bit smaller than the PTE T3 .63A/R. A Garrett GT42R 1.01 A/R divided T4 housing sounds huge, but it's really comparable to a T4 .68 undivided.

Spoolup can often more come down to cams, exhaust manifold design(huge), intake manifold, boost leaks, ignition timing, etc. The worst looking pile of shit true log manifold will usually spool a turbo the quickest, but have a big performance hit in the upper RPMs. Long runner fancy top mount manifolds no matter how perfectly they are design are usually laggy, which is fine if you need to make power from 8000-10000 RPMs.

I did one car with 3 different kinds of exhaust manifolds on the same turbo and saw 1000+ RPM spoolup difference from the worst to the best. eBay manifold spooled ok, but power was blah. Tried a fancy top mount, gained about 40hp, but 500 more rpms of lag. Tried a short runner tubular and made the same power as the top mount but spooled 1000 rpms quicker than the top mount and 500 quicker than the eBay.

I haven't had any BW or Holset turbos on the dyno that really blew me away as spooling way faster or making huge amounts more power. Some of those turbos are quite good, but not anything magic. The huge BWs(S372 and bigger) do spool pretty good for their size, but we aren't talking worlds different than others. It's hard to compare different cars, dynos, setups, etc over the internet to each other. The FP setups are usually noticably quicker spooling than comparable Garrett setups, but a lot of people use the FP exhaust manifold with them too.

turbotalon1g 11-04-2008 10:22 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
^Thanks man. You've been a lot of help with a lot of questions.

Well I am thinking about keeping the FP Mani I have and just getting the bolt-on housing. I think anything I can do to keep spool would be good plus I only log a max on 38 lb/min now so even if I do get to 49 lb/min I will love it.

Halon 11-04-2008 10:31 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
What about something like a 20G in a 7cm housing? Might be able to find a used one around for a decent price. Should still spool decently, give you a little more top end, bolt up to your mani, just have to figure out a WG setup for it.

sleepydsm 11-04-2008 10:44 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
I'm gonna sound dumb, the when referenceing the 6cm^2/7cm^2 they are talking about the area of the turbo exhaust housing inlet, correct? Like for example, the stock 14bs are 6cm^2 and cool people use that mitsu gasket and port them to 7cm^2. Or am I retarded.

asshanson 11-04-2008 10:52 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
You're thinking of the diameter of the turbine housing inlet, 6cm across, not 6cm^2 area.

sleepydsm 11-04-2008 11:11 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
oops.

jrohner 11-05-2008 01:10 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
I've been looking into upgrading to a Holset. This is about all I've been reading about online lately. From what I've found, full boost (hx35) is around 3500 rpms and capable of 500awhp all with the DSM bolt-on housing. 52 lbs/min for the hx35, and 2-3 less for the h1c. 60 something for the hx40 (I don't want anything that big so haven't cared about the exact number) -- 650hp so probably 65+ lbs/min and with full boost by low to mid 4 grand. Pretty awesome spool vs hp I would say. I'm probably throwing an h1c on my car.

At-Least-It's-An-Evo 11-05-2008 08:37 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jrohner (Post 263471)
From what I've found, full boost (hx35) is around 3500 rpms and capable of 500awhp all with the DSM bolt-on housing.


How much "full boost" at 3500? Maybe 20 psi on a 2.4L and a HX35, but I highly doubt 30 psi by 3500 on a typical 2.0L or any boost level that would make 500awhp. I'd like to see these dyno charts. I think the honda-tech disease is spreading to the dsm world. (I made 600whp on my gt35r and 10 psi and full boost by 2000rpms!)

jrohner 11-05-2008 11:07 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by At-Least-It's-An-Evo (Post 263493)
How much "full boost" at 3500? Maybe 20 psi on a 2.4L and a HX35, but I highly doubt 30 psi by 3500 on a typical 2.0L or any boost level that would make 500awhp. I'd like to see these dyno charts. I think the honda-tech disease is spreading to the dsm world. (I made 600whp on my gt35r and 10 psi and full boost by 2000rpms!)

Then go look for them if you actually care. Look up something before you go slamming it.

If you run a bigger t3 housing it will take over 4 grand to spool on a 2.0. People have said the hx35 starts making boost sooner than a 16g so it's not quite as hard of a hit. It would be lame if it took a 2.4 to build boost by 3500, that would probably be worse than a 50 trim not better.

At-Least-It's-An-Evo 11-05-2008 11:14 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jrohner (Post 263517)
Then go look for them if you actually care. Look up something before you go slamming it.

Nope, I don't care. Nor do I care for a HX35 or the bullseye housing for it. It's too small of a turbo anyways.

Saying it gets "full boost" and putting that it makes 500whp in the same sentence makes it sound like if you are gonna run the 30 psi it'll take to make that power, that it'd make it by 3500 is all I'm saying, and we know that's probably not the case like how Honda-tech'ers always forget to say that their boost crept up to 15 psi to make that 500whp.

If you have the opportunity/finances Aaron, get a T3 housing unless you're gonna get some FP housing. Just my opinion.

jrohner 11-05-2008 11:24 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by At-Least-It's-An-Evo (Post 263521)
Nope, I don't care. Nor do I care for a HX35 or it's bullseye housing. It's too small anyways.

...and we know that's probably not the case...

Posting about something you don't care about and don't know about. Always a good combination.

So you're speaking for everyone now. OK.

The poster is interested in the HX35 and 50 trims, yet you're saying an HX35 is too small? For who? This thread was started by "turbotalon1g", why don't you keep it about what he wants. My 16G broke 400 hp so how is a turbo that's rated for 12 lbs/min higher too small?

At-Least-It's-An-Evo 11-05-2008 11:27 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jrohner (Post 263523)
Don't post if you don't care and don't know. Read about it so you know what you are talking about. You sound like one who has a huge turbo and doesn't break 400 hp.

So you're speaking for everyone now. OK.

Don't know? Yep, that's just it. All I can say is welcome to 5 years ago.

JET 11-05-2008 11:31 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jrohner (Post 263523)
Posting about something you don't care about and don't know about. Always a good combination.

So you're speaking for everyone now. OK.

Well, he made over 600 whp on his DSM. You are the one that made the statement, you should have the information to back it up. It sounds like you are talking about boost threshold and not full boost. In your research you must have run across a dyno chart to back that up, just post a link to prove your point.

jrohner 11-05-2008 11:35 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Making 600 hp doesn't mean he knows about a turbo he doesn't run. I'd like to see his torque and rpm range.

jrohner 11-05-2008 11:38 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JET (Post 263528)
Well, he made over 600 whp on his DSM. You are the one that made the statement, you should have the information to back it up. It sounds like you are talking about boost threshold and not full boost. In your research you must have run across a dyno chart to back that up, just post a link to prove your point.

I don't see how you can go by a dyno chart to tell you where full boost is. I make full boost by 2800 on my car, a hair over 3000 in 3rd gear, yet the dyno chart shows it at like 3800 and peak torque at 4200, both on the DD and Dynojet. The load is far different on a dyno than the street where it matters. The main chart I've seen on the HX35 had peak torque at 5 grand and made about 500 hp at about 7 grand at 25psi. It doesn't tell you where it makes full boost on the street, you have to go by what people say -- which is what I'm doing. This other guy is just saying 'I don't care what anyone says it's not possible' basically. Have you had one on your car or ridden with someone to really say it's not possible?

Besides, tune means a lot too, I can change my spool 400 rpms easy just using a different timing map. I was making full boost at 3200 and then I changed my timing and now I'm at 27-2800. It doesn't make a big difference what psi I'm running either, rpm is very close to the same.

At-Least-It's-An-Evo 11-05-2008 11:46 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jrohner (Post 263529)
I swear every thread on here turns into this crap.

What crap, a thread full of false information? Yep. Only if there are people to provide it.

Super Bleeder!! 11-05-2008 11:55 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Whats the highest trap achieved with an hx35 on a dsm?

jrohner 11-05-2008 11:59 AM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Super Bleeder!! (Post 263533)
Whats the highest trap achieved with an hx35 on a dsm?


Not sure yet, there is a results thread that people are starting to post, I haven't read through the whole 15916616465456565 pages of holset info. I've seen around 125-130mph so far. I do highly doubt all those pages are false information.

I wouldn't be thinking about switching to one if I could hold a few more psi with my 16g.

JET 11-05-2008 12:15 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jrohner (Post 263530)
I don't see how you can go by a dyno chart to tell you where full boost is. I make full boost by 2800 on my car, a hair over 3000 in 3rd gear, yet the dyno chart shows it at like 3800 and peak torque at 4200, both on the DD and Dynojet. The load is far different on a dyno than the street where it matters. The main chart I've seen on the HX35 had peak torque at 5 grand and made about 500 hp at about 7 grand at 25psi. It doesn't tell you where it makes full boost on the street, you have to go by what people say -- which is what I'm doing. This other guy is just saying 'I don't care what anyone says it's not possible' basically. Have you had one on your car or ridden with someone to really say it's not possible?

Besides, tune means a lot too, I can change my spool 400 rpms easy just using a different timing map. I was making full boost at 3200 and then I changed my timing and now I'm at 27-2800. It doesn't make a big difference what psi I'm running either, rpm is very close to the same.

Going on heresay is just BS. Yes a dyno spools later than the street, but you can still compare much better than some guys saying I spool mine at XXXX! If the dyno shows one turbo spools 500 rpm sooner than the other one, you will see a very similar difference on the street. That is the significance of the dyno chart. Tune is always going to matter, that is why you don't go off of just 1 dyno chart, but look at several. What gear you are in also makes a big difference.

jrohner 11-05-2008 12:24 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
More boost doesn't always mean more hp. Some turbo's have less boost at a certain rpm but still give you more hp. Same goes for your setup and tune.

I remember reading an article in a magazine a few years back, I think it was about a galant vr4, where they put on a bigger turbo that made full boost at a higher rpm yet made more torque at that lower amount of boost. If all the air coming out of the turbo went directly into the cylinders, there wouldn't really be any boost pressure.

At-Least-It's-An-Evo 11-05-2008 12:32 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jrohner (Post 263543)
More boost doesn't always mean more hp. Some turbo's have less boost at a certain rpm but still give you more hp.

It's called efficiency and turbo sizing.

Dyno's like a Dyno Dynamics and some Mustang ones can simulate the street driving load and the spool can be very comparable on those dynos.

Dyno charts tell alot. So do Standalone logs.

FattyBoomBatty 11-05-2008 12:54 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
I left a standalone log in the toilet this morning.

User Name 11-05-2008 01:04 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by FattyBoomBatty (Post 263548)
I left a standalone log in the toilet this morning.

Yes!!!

Oh and uh..Mitsu housing.

wheelhop 12-22-2008 04:44 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Wow! I expected this in June; not in November after this seasons results have been posted.

Ok. No heresay. My car, my turbo. H1C bolt-on housing 54mm compressor inducer and 84mm compressor exducer (50-trim/20g flow potential at better high boost efficiency), turbine wheel about the size of an t350 (t3 stage 5) turbine wheel. Fp2 cams with stock manifolds on a 2.0L motor: 28psi by 3600rpms. 20+ psi by 3400rpms. ON THE ROAD. My small 16g spooled the same with the same setup. The h1c has the hx35 turbine wheel with a slightly smaller compressor. The hx35 has a 56mm inducer.

Maglin, on dsmtuners, full boost (30psi) by 3600rpms with the hx35.

Same turbo has done 11.2@126mph with the same bolt-on housing at 28psi stock weight. These results at 28psi with no manifold upgrades and just 272s is not indicative of a turbine that is sacrificing flow for spool.

494whp @ 25psi. Typical boltons, including the bolton housing. No exhaust manifold upgrade. Considering the above trap speed this would be expected with 3psi less boost.

There's plenty more. If you really care, you'll look. If you don't, you won't call BS without proof yourself. But I do agree that the bep turbine housing is too small for poor flowing poor spooling garret T turbine wheels. And I do agree that the bolton housing is a choke to the later 60lb/min hx35 compressor wheel, of which has the same spool speed. The t3 bep turbine housing or the stock hx35 t3 turbine housing with the stock hx35 turbine wheel is proven to flow enough for 600whp (based on trap speeds not inconsistant dyno numbers) and spools to 20+ psi ON THE ROAD by 3900-4000rpms. When can a td06 20g spool to 20+ psi :) ?

Kracka 12-22-2008 04:52 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wheelhop (Post 269725)
When can a td06 20g spool to 20+ psi :) ?

I was able to spool my 20G to 19psi by 3500 rpm. '94 Talon TSi fwd; stock 7-bolt 2.0L 4G63. It actually spooled faster than my ported/clipped Big 16G.

scheides 12-22-2008 04:59 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kracka (Post 269728)
I was able to spool my 20G to 19psi by 3500 rpm. '94 Talon TSi fwd; stock 7-bolt 2.0L 4G63. It actually spooled faster than my ported/clipped Big 16G.

Was it a full TD06 turbine wheel? Most DSM 20G's back in the day were TD05 for improved response.

Kracka 12-22-2008 05:01 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
I don't know for sure to be honest. I remember being told it was but that was many years ago and I have no pictures of to reminisce to. I bought it from Nash and was also told it was used on an HKS drag car way back in the day at one time. Then, I sold it to Brian (1quick4) who later sold it to Peter. Last I knew the turbo was still on Peter's old blue GSX; maybe he has a picture.

wheelhop 12-22-2008 05:05 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
From my experience with the 20g turbos I've used and tuned. That is the spool speed of a td05h 20g. Nice turbo but the turbine is restrictive, since it is the 16g turbine. It won't flow much more than the evo3 16g, no matter how big the compressor wheel is. The evo3 16g compressor can even benefit from a larger turbine. . .

Pushit2.0 12-22-2008 06:18 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
From what I recall that was a tdo5 20g.

Kracka 12-22-2008 06:20 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Thanks for the clarification dudes!

Speedfreak 12-22-2008 07:04 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Different turbo's make different hp #'s at the same boost level?

wheelhop 12-22-2008 07:35 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
:) yes. If not then we would all have the same turbine wheel and turbine housing.

turbotalon1g 12-22-2008 07:42 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Well I have a HX35 with bolton housing on the way. I have a T3 manifold for sale and I haven't decided if I am keeping this other HX35

wheelhop 12-22-2008 07:59 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Which compressor wheel does each have? The 7blade 56mm compressor wheel will spool the same as the 8blade 56mm compressor wheel using the bep housing. It flows 60lb/min. If if you want more turbo later you can get the t3 bep housing or use a used 12cm^2 hx35 turbine housing (t3 bolt pattern) and have enough turbo to make 570ish whp. And with either turbine housing spool will be between 3900 and 4100rpms.

EDIT: To add, if you stick with bolton . . . In the meantime, you will have a turbo that will spool as fast as an evo3 16g/td05h 18g/tdo5h 20g, but flow as much as a td06 20g or t31 50-trim.

Speedfreak 12-22-2008 09:52 PM

Re: T3 vs. Mitsu housing
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Speedfreak (Post 269774)
Different turbo's make different hp #'s at the same boost level?

Quote:

Originally Posted by wheelhop (Post 269778)
:) yes. If not then we would all have the same turbine wheel and turbine housing.

I was making fun of this thread. :biggrin:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:07 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.